Month: April 2010

  • Trekathon 188: Reunion (TNG)

    OK, that’s it. My suspicion about the writer’s doing the deliberately bad opening to good episodes is pretty much confirmed, as an excellent Klingon episode is started with Worf’s son showing up. (And that’s certainly a justified view – most of the Alexander episodes are, from memory, pretty bad). The only thing I didn’t like…

  • Trekathon 187: Legacy (TNG)

    This was a dull episode with little in the way of redeeming qualities. Oh yay, Tasha’s sister (who we’ve never heard of before) turns up. Then there’s an interminably long sequence where she builds trust and a relationship with Data, and then she betrays everything. I think the idea was doomed from the start -…

  • Trekathon 186: Remember Me (TNG)

    Rather than the whole ship, this time Wesley tries to kill his mother. I don’t think he was paying enough attention during his study of Greek Myth. This was a really well done bait-and-switch. It takes a while before the episode even clearly establishes that there’s something really weird going on. But seriously – sure…

  • Trekathon 185: Suddenly Human (TNG)

    After a wrong of some pretty strong episodes, this one was black to ‘bleh’ – Picard learns how to be a parent. It really, really bugged me throughout the episode that no one was even considering the option that maybe it be best for the child to stay with the family that has raised him…

  • Trekathon 184: Brothers (TNG)

    So: Data has shown he has a security vulnerability that allows someone to remotely give him orders, and he *also* has the ability to single handedly take control of the Enterprise against the will of everyone else on board. Surely at least a minor security review is called for. Rather than just letting him back…

  • Trekathon 183: Family (TNG)

    This episode is pure soap opera, but in a good way. It’s testament to the strength of the characters that have been built up over the course of the series that this episode is even possible, without even a hint of anything beyond pure character reactions to drive the plot forward. Another sign of the…

  • Trekathon 182: The Best of Both Worlds, Part II (TNG)

    It is a real and genuine problem of two-part episodes like this hat the second part is a bit of a let down. The first episode gets to set up incredible situations, like that guy in the meeting with the incredible ideas. The second episode has to be the guy in the meeting who has…

  • Trekathon Season Review: The Next Generation, Season 3

    What a difference a year makes. Season 1 of Next Generation was overall pretty bad. Season 2 was better, but not without significant problems. Season 3 finally pulled it all together, and is the best season of Star Trek that I’ve watched so far. The margin over the second season of Original Star Trek is…

  • Trekathon 181: The Best of Both Worlds (TNG)

    I tried really hard to pick fault with this episode while watching it – it makes writing these summaries a lot easier. But I was at a loss, this is a nearly flawless piece of work. The episode starts with as soft a reintroduction of the Borg as possible, and then simply cranks the stakes…

  • Trekathon 180: Transfigurations (TNG)

    A nice excursion into a traditional high SF idea – the next step of evolution. The thing that stood out for me in this episode was the willingness of the writing to give the events some time to develop. This episode unfolds over a longer period than any other episode I can think of, several…